Shi Shi Shi Shi - Chinese Pinyin
By Jian Shuo Wang on 2009-06-07 22:14 · ArtAs many people knows, there are many different characters mapping to the same pronunciation. Thus, it is very hard to directly tell from a pronunciation what the original character is. Here is an interesting example, written by Zhao Yuan Ren in 1930.
石室诗士施氏,嗜食狮,誓食十狮。适施氏时时适市视狮。十时,适十狮适市。是时,适施氏适市。氏视是十狮,恃矢势,使是十狮逝世。氏拾是十狮尸,适石室。石室湿,氏使侍拭石室。石室拭,氏始试食是十狮尸。食时,始识是十狮尸,实十石狮尸。试释是事。
If you directly use Pinyin to translate the article into something people from other countries can at least pronounce, just like people translate my name from my Chinese name to Wang Jian Shuo, here is the translation:
Shi Shi shi shi shi
Shishi shishi Shi Shi, shi shi, shi shi shi shi.
Shi shishi shi shi shi shi.
shi shi, shi shi shi shi shi.
Shi shi, shi Shi Shi shi shi.
Shi shi shi shi shi, shi shi shi, shi shi shi shi shishi.
Shi shi shi shi shi shi, shi shishi.
Shishi shi, Shi shi shi shi shishi.
Shishi shi, Shi shi shi shi shi shi shi.
Shi shi, shi shi shi shi shi, shi shi shi shi.
Shi shi shi shi.
I know it is nightmare to read it.
Here is my translation of the article (well, just roughly)
A poet with last name Shi living in a room made of stone,
loved lions, and sware to eat ten lions.
Shi often go to market to see lions.
At ten o’clock, it happened that ten lions came to the market.
At thsi time, it happened that this Mr. Shi came to the market.
Mr. Shi looked at the ten lions, and used the power of arch, killed the ten lions.
Mr. Shi picked up the body of the ten lions, and got to the stone room.
The stone room was wet, Mr. Shi asked servant wipe the stone room.
The stone room was done, Mr. Shi started to try to eat the body of the ten lions.
When he started eating, he found out the ten lion body were actually ten stone lion body.
Try explaion this.
15 Comments
古人的文功很有趣,不过在今天,文功已经不是什么重要的东西了。一个文字如何表意一个人的声音确实是件事情。可能这个人没有经过嗓子就把它的声音发出来了。
今天还能捉摸到这种文字乐趣的人不多。
除却文功以外,这篇文章的构思亦是相当精巧,也是非常了不起的。
我认为,写文章不但要音容并貌,而且情节也很重要。这方面较有特色的金庸是一个。钱钟书如果不是过于学术化了一点,在文学方面可能更有成就一些。
讲起这种写作的乐趣。就是看到好文章的时候时时会想起。
Is the sound of each word exactly the same or there is a difference in the tone?
If the sound of each word is exactly the same, then you can only understand the poem when you read it. If someone recited the poem to you, you would have the same problem as reading it in pinyin.
If that is true, then there are poems that cannot be recited in Chinese at all. They can only be read
Pinyin is a representation of the sound of the language. A phonetic alphabet. If a language have too many words which sound is exactly the same, then purely phonetic system is useless,... unless enhanced in someway.
For example. In the same way in which some phonetic alphabets use special signs to indicate the right sound of a tone, special punctuation marks could be added to distinguish words with same sound but different meaning. That is similar to what it is done with Chinese characters, although in a different way.
You could have a Pinyin++.
But if my assumptions are correct, the problem of hearing that "shii" poem remains the same. You can understand it when you, buy not when you hear it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinyin
There are many Chinese characters whose pronunciations differ only in their tones. As you can see here, 32 of such characters are in this poem alone :-)
You are absolutely right: No body will understand it without reading it.
英文的文化含义更多的是外向,表面的,急于表达的。不像中国内在的,含蓄的,逻辑性强的。要把这首《石室诗士施氏》翻译成英文才是搞笑了。所以中国人为什么会更聪明些。语言是个重要的因素。英文只有26个字母,在人脑中,这26个图型的处理只是分别它的排序方式不同。但中文的字形却是千变万化,无形中加大了人脑的处理压力。因为处理这些中国字需要不断的进行图形的逻辑转换。这是个工作量极大的CPU过程。久而久之,中国人的脑子就这么锻炼出来了。
所以中国有种说法叫文字而劳形。讲的就是,中国文字带来的疲劳感,常常会使人精神不振。通俗点讲,就是用脑过度。
对吧,王建硕。这种内在的东西,大家都懂的吧。
以前我跟别人玩。别人将非常垃圾的东西来挑战我。我就跟那帮社区网管干。结果,到把我练出来了。
Fascinating. If too many words do not differ at all in sound, only in Chinese character used, then the pinyin system would have to be augmented with extra characters and/or symbols to solve these phonetics ambiguities of the Chinese languages.
Just a pure phonetic alphabet seems not to be enough.
How this could be done, or if the end result would be easier or more conveniet to use than the Chinese characters (classic or simplified), I have no idea.
http://www.phonetics.ucla.edu/vowels/chapter2/cantonese/recording2.2.html
Also, I think calling this "fascinating" is a little disingenuous. Chinese having sentences that are unintelligible to the ear isn't anything particular. English has a similar sentence - Buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo. This sentence can be made infinitely long using only "Buffalo" and "buffalo," unlike the Chinese story. Anyway, what I want to say is that I can't stand people who think things foreign are "fascinating" mostly because they're foreign.
As to Mr. 也许知道, 平声和仄声是用来写诗的。平声是阴平阳平,其他(上去入)都是仄声。可是平仄不会告诉你一个字到底是哪个声哪个调,所以不能靠平仄来猜字。
"英文的文化含义更多的是外向,表面的,急于表达的。不像中国内在的,含蓄的,逻辑性强的。"
又是这套笼统的傻话。这才没有逻辑性。也没啥根据;这些东西人哪里能分得这么清楚?
Also, I don't think you should be so dismissive of verb conjugation. Wouldn't one think that the imperfect subjunctive in French has more internal (内在) meaning than a plain old one-form Chinese verb?
我最后说一下,赵元任是一个世界上非常罕见的奇才,他没写这个东西就可能永远没有人写。
If the foreigners wanted to learn Chinese lets learn it without using the romanised pinyin. I wonder if Japanese have romanised japanese?
Sometime when I listened to the Chinese press conference, there are always translation comes with it. The French, British, Spain, Japanese, their government wouldn't bother to provide translation. If the world want to know what the chinese government is trying to say they shoudl learn Chinese.
The Japanese do have romanized japanese, for learners of Japanese as a second language. As for over-use of pinyin within China and English translations of domestic news conferences (I assume you don't mean international press conferences, because every country translates international stuff, even if the translations are given directly to the press rather than publicly released), you'll have to take that up with the Chinese government. It's not the foreigners who are writing the translations and romanizations you know.