Do Chinese Move to Small Cities
By Jian Shuo Wang on 2005-02-01 11:26 · CulturePC is an investor running Investor Diary in Hong Kong. He is also a good friend of mine after we exchanged some emails. He dropped me an email today and discussed about the idea of moving to smaller cities.
Dear Jian Shuo,
In the US an increasing number of people choose to live outside of the big cities because of lower costs of living and better quality of live. See http://www.forbes.com/bestplaces/2005/01/20/life2land05.html
I wonder if the same can be applied to China. Apart from the big cities like Beijing and Shanghai, are there smaller cities in China that are cheaper and nicer (e.g. air quality, population density etc.) to live? For example, what about places like Tsing Dao?
Maybe that can be a topic for your post later on. Anyway just a thought.
Kind regards,
PC
PC, thanks for the good topic. Yes. I will write about it.
Moving into Cities? It is a Dream
China is still at the stage of urbanization. It remains a dream for the 0.6 billion population in country-side to move into cities. They struggle for their whole life to get a city Hukou so they can move into cities. If they don’t get the Hukou, they are called farmer workers, with no health insurance, no education opportunities
To enter a collage is one of the very few ways to get a city Hukou. I have friends who tried more than 5 times for the collage examinations. It was 5 years of waiting and trying. If he didn’t try, he will remain a farmer for the rest of his life (before the Hukou system changes).
Moving into Largest Cities? It is a Dream
For people in smallest cities, they want to go to bigger cities like Luoyang (which has 6 million population). There are more job possibilities there.
For people in these middle sized cities, like me, they try to move to bigger cities. People in Shanghai or Beijing have many benefits which people in other cities don’t have. Let’s take education opportunity as an example.
In Henan Province, only 1 out of 5 students has the chance to enter university at the time I completed my high school, while in Shanghai, the ratio was about 4 out of 5. In Beijing, the ratio is higher.
Shanghai Jiao Tong University accepted 56 students from Henan province (with a population of 100 million) while accepted several hundred from Shanghai (with population of 12 million at that time). When I was in grade two or three in high school, some of my friends transferred to high school in Beijing or Shanghai. The reason is simple. In Luoyang, they worried about whether they could be accepted by a colleague, while in Beijing, they only worry about whether they can enter Tsinghua or Peking Univ. That is the difference.
Besides education, the job opportunity, the income, the city facility in bigger cities are better. I never heard of drama or symphony performance in Luoyang, but I can see them in Shanghai. It seems everything in big city is better in smaller city - except the hot competition, the high pressure and the bad air.
There are too many people looking for opportunities to enter biggest cities like Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, while so less thinking about moving out.
Moving Out to Smaller Cities? It is Also a Dream
For those who already have good life in Shanghai, sometimes, they may be attempted to move out of bigger cities when they bear too much pressure. It’s just like say “Hey, I hope I can stay at the sand beach for the rest of my life.” It is a dream that no one really get it.
Wendy and I joked: If we sell out our house and we move back to Luoyang, maybe we don’t have to work for the rest of the life. The living standard in Luoyang is low and everything is cheap. In a city where people with 200 RMB monthly income can lead pretty good life, we have many 200 RMB to spend. We can lead happy life there. It is only a dream. There are too many things we cannot give up.
Wendy’s friends, a couple with a newly-born child, once told me about the same dream. They are alone in Shanghai and no one takes care of their child - both of them need to work and an Ayi is not helpful enough to take of the newly-born child. After several months of life like “working at day time and taking care of the child till early morning”, they really thought about giving up the high pressure life in Shanghai and go back to the small town. We said, we all have the dream, but how can we really do it?
Nice Small Cities
There are some very nice smaller cities in China. Here are some on my life:
Dalian in Liaoning Province
Tsingtao (or Qing Dao) in Shandong Province
Xiamen in Fujan Province
Sanya in Hainan Province
Beihai in Guangxi Province
Suzhou in Jiangsu Province
…
The list can be long. They are really nice with good view or environment. People are nice and the pace of living is slow. However, I don’t think it feasible to move. You can not get 1/3 of the salary you get here. If someone does not need to work, and he/she just want to find sometime to retire, he/she can do it. Dalian or Qingdao is good choice.
Move? It is not Easy in China
U.S. is a country on cars. People pack up everything and drive to a new city to settle down. Since the country is the immigrated country, it is common for people to move.
China is not. Moving was traditionally considered to be very bad thing. The last thing people in China will do (traditionally) is to move home. We call it Bei Jing Li Xiang 背井离乡, or directly translated to English: Go away from the well and leave one’s home town. If there is not disaster in that area, people do not move.
Recently, the metropolitan like Shanghai attracted many people to do it, for sake of the family’s future, they move. Many move only for better education for next generation. For sake of children is still the #1 reason for those who immigrate to Canada. It is very rare to see someone to move back to smaller cities. I never heard about it so far.
China is different. It is at the stage when everyone rushes to cities. Maybe after several years, when people are more mobilized, a very small portion of the population may think about moving out. In Shanghai, people have cars started to move out of the downtown and move into the town house out side the Outer Ring. It is a positive sign of the future move.
**Conclusion: **
To move from smaller cities into bigger cities is a dream that many people have realized. To move from bigger cities out to smaller cities is also a dream that no one takes it seriously.
P.S. Steve-O flattered me to be the “nicest guy in the world!” today. Maybe. But I am the happiest guy in the world when I got your comment. Thank you Steve-O!
32 Comments
Regarding your topic about moving to smaller cities, I would like to say a few words about it.
The cities you listed, actually in America and most European countries are considered a big city. Any city has population over several millions are not smaller city. As to compare with metropolitan huge cities, like Shanghai, Beijing, New York, Tokyo, London, and Paris, maybe it is small. As to Hong Kong, their population is about 5-6 millions. Is Hong Kong a big city or small? maybe we should include city size(square mile) and population density to decide whether the city is big or small.
In America, people live in surbanban of a major city, is mostly financially ahead of the people live in crowd inner city. If developer can plan surbanban cities around Shanghai and Beijing, people will move out of the inner city if the traffic is acceptable and easily accessible. I personaly feel that Shanghai city government should or would have a developmental plan soon or later to make satellite cities or towns surrounding Shanghai more attractive. I believe that they need time to achieve this. America and European countries took many years to achieve, probably so Shanghai and Beijing should too.
James
PS: They do have luxurious and expensive apartments in New York city.
In China, the choose between city and suburb, bigger city or smaller city is not as simple as to choose a place to live. It means a lot other than that, as I described in the article.
Thanks for your very informative post which reminded me that it's not that easy to move within China. I recall when I was living in Shanghai last year, a friend had so much trouble trying to get a Hukou in Shanghai.
Admittedly China and US are at very different stages of development. The former is a developing country where people are just trying to get ahead by going to the big cities with more opportunities whereas the latter is a fully developed country where people are looking for better quality of life in smaller cities and want to escape the rat race.
In the longer term when China becomes richer, the preference for surburbs or smaller city living should increase.
Also thanks to everyone else for their very insightful comments.
Just one observation - please correct me if I'm mistaken. Suzhou (Wendy's favorite?), Jiangsu is mentioned in your post. Isn't this city doing very well economically and as a result the costs of living there are significantly higher than the other medium-sized city listed above?
Tsingtao (Qingdao), population 6 or 7 million (2.4 urban, acc. UN)
Xiamen, population 2.2 million (1.3 in urban)
Sanya, population 0.5 million
Beihai, population 1.4 million (0.2 or 1.0 in urban, 3.7 as UN forecast for 2015)
Suzhou, population 1.5 million (1.2 acc. UN; 2.2 urban and 5.9 metro acc. to Suzhou.gov)
...
OK, perhaps Sanya counts as a "small city" for a while...
http://www2.eur.nl/fsw/research/happiness/hap_nat/nat_fp.htm
I wonder if the chinese counting had been achieved only by those who can read english ????
Then it will be less than "something very small" part of the total population in China !
Note the top (danish) rank, though..... no. 1 !
There must be good reasons, huh ?
Find out on the homepage beyond the survey.
http://www2.eur.nl/fsw/research/happiness/hap_nat/findingreports/RankReport2004-1c.htm
When China annex Hong Kong in 1997, one country two systems, and in 1999, Macau returned to China, one country three systems, should Taiwan unifies with China in the future, one country four systems. Is there a better way to express equality for majority people within the same country?
Stephen
It is about equality and basic human right!
Stephen
james
China is not 'popularizing' education and high living standard, but 'polarizing' it between top tier and bottom tier citizens by mean of 'hukou'. As mentioned by Jianshuo, university acceptance rate from rural is lower as compared to city dwellers, without education, rural residents' ability to make wealth is limited.
Should one day you become the ruling class, how are you going to tackle the desire of the vast majority of population to receive better education and treatment like the elite few receive today?
Stephen
So interesting to read about developments of cities and future suburbs in your amazing country. I can envision both megopolises forming in rings. But I can also envision what you call your smaller cities, ie. Dalian, Tsingtao, etc. developing and coming unto their own so to speak. This appears to agree with the Chinese sense of antiquity. And you would not have the problem of future "traffic jam" from big city to suburb.
As for education in smaller cities, much can be accomplished via satellite today. Ask India!
Ann
Second I want to say I am mad those people like chengb02. Who do they think they are.
My book for the HuKou system is semi-serf system.
I was from China, from country-side. Now I am living in America. After I came to US, I sensed the huge difference between China and America, about the equality of each person, non-discrimination, human rights. I know Chinese people in China may not like to hear this word, but this is the most important issue for a human being.
I still hold GuangZhou's HuKou. I had been in GuangZhou for 6 years. Although I were one of those who has the privilleges over other "out siders", I was one of the benificiaries of the hukou system after I got into one of the best university by hard working and luck, but I am shame of the system.
Why people in Beijing discriminate people in Luoyang (JS, do not say no, you know it's there), why people in the city discriminate our brothers and sisters from country-side? They are same race as you people in the city, they speak same language as city-people do, constitutionaly they are citizens of China. Why they are deprived their rights to get equal opportunities for education, for job, for social benefit?
Any American citizen can move to NYC freely, can find a job freely, can let their children go to schools in NYC. Why as Chinese citizen we can not move to Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou freely? Are Beijing University and TsingHua University funded only by BeiJing people? Too much.
While I am in US, I go to watch college football, I go to watch NBA game. During those events, the audience sing the US national song (forget the proper word) with passion from their heart. Why, because US deserves their love. They are treated by this country as a human being.
We Chinese always complain about the inequality that foreigners treat us. My opinion is that as the day we Chinese still do not treat our own citizen equally, don't expect other will treat us equally.
Tristan
I understood how you felt about 'hukou' which derive a series of other problems, both socially and possibly politically. I wonder that cities, towns, and villages have their own 'hukou' registry. People will receive subsidiary from government when almost everything is lacking and need to be distributed acording to need. The rice and cooking oil etc. keep people going and alive. It is also a statistics and security measure. This is a brief explanation about 'hukou'. It existed at least 8 years while Japanese occupied China. 'hukou' itself is not a bad thing, just like registry and identity in western countries. The only problem is the benefits 'hukou' provide. That's one of the main reason why people like to migrate to the city with better benefit. Of course, better opportunities, too. If there is no benefit and subsidiary from the 'hukou', 'hukou' is just a registry and identity tool. Everyone has to pay tax to enjoy benefits from the city. Local, international and transient residents are alike. That's my opinion.
I would not agree tht 'hukou' could cause equality and human right violation. Both equality and human rights are relative things. It is hard to measure. Unfortunately relative equality and less human right are always there. If we can achieve basic equality and human rights, itwill be very blesssed. What is the basic equality and human right. Do you have a definition?Democratic government with liberty does not necessary a sound government and lead people to have better lives. India is one of the example. The rich and poor in India is wide. There almost no middle class. Middle class I believe, is the backbone of a country as well as in society. Democracy, equality and human rights are wonderful. Unfortunately we are born unequally. If you are lucky, you are bron in a civilized rich world with developed equality, democracy and human rights. If you are unlucky, the road is long, curved and ragged. That's why I say we are unequal when we are born. The beautiful name of equality, yes, we should pursue, probably with a price. Hopefully, the price is not too high and acceptable. It is a real big issue. I don't think that anyone can solve that puzzle without a serious fight. Time will tell.
James.
We Chinese people never lack patriotism, we do not need more. We were great before, that fact should not stop us puring a better China, in modern standard.
Everyday a lot of crap happens everyday even in a democratic society, but with democratic way there is always a rational way to solve those problems. If India is really bad like James says, the problem is not from democracy, it has its inner roots. And I think we should take EU, Japan, US, Canada as our model for learning, instead take India's case to let us feel good about ourselves. That's not a nation with high self-esteem, high expectation should do.
Wake up, "middle class" comrades, after you have your house, your car, do something good to China by changing yourself to be a modern citizen.
--- Tristan
PS. I like the discussions in this way. ;-)
WHAT ABOUT THOSE MAINLAND HAIRSTYLES ?
WHATS THE DEAL WITH THOSE WILD HAICUTS THAT HAVE THE CHICKEN THING STICKING UP IN ALL DIRECTIONS?
ANSWER ME THAT !
Economically the "country" in Asian countries have crumbling infrastructure, low levels of education, lousy pay and generally a lower standard of living for its people. However there is a sharp contrast in more developed nations. In regions such as Western Europe and North America, the countryside is not wealthier as a whole but in terms of per capita it is (that is people from the country are richer than the people in the cities; generally speaking). This can be due to the fact to lower population density and government subsidies for farmers etc...
Socially Asian people (that come from poorer Asian nations) tend to view peasants from the country with disdain because of the crime rate, poverty, level of education most receive and the perception of backwardness. Again it is the complete opposite in more developed nations, where the quality of basic infrastructure and level of education is almost on par with those from the major cities. And crime rates are generally lower because poverty is almost non-existent. So people's perception of the countryside are generally more positive when compared to people from developed nations. For example take the numerous Western films such as Babe or Smallville; where the countryside is portrayed as clean cut and very peaceful, whereas people from the cities are all cunningly sly and un-contented and usually interfering in the towns folk's peaceful existence.
Spiritually, yes I made this up, it is important to consider many people from poorer Asian nations tend to have ambitions of monetary success. Whereas people in richer regions tend to want a better quality or more fulfilling level of life. This can be due to many factors, but it is probably due to the fact that many Asians are poor and are therefore struggling to survive (e.g China and India) whereas in America people are generally economically sorted so-to-speak. Both are striding for the em-betterment for themselves, but because of their backgrounds both possess different ambitions to try and achieve spiritual content.
These are the differences between China and the USA regarding why the Chinese as a whole do not move to inland regions of China. As for "Do Chinese move to Small Cities"? I would think so out of a population of 1300000000 people, but the surge from the wave caused by those moving from the country to the Eastern cities dwarfs that figure. Lets face it, right now there are more poor in China than there are rich (obviously), but who know in 20 years the trend in China then might be the same as the trend in the USA today.
As the saying goes "money makes the world go round"! There is probably a lot more to add, but I will refrain myself from hijacking this discussion lol...
P.S. Lim
Economically the "country" in Asian countries have crumbling infrastructure, low levels of education, lousy pay and generally a lower standard of living for its people. However there is a sharp contrast in more developed nations. In regions such as Western Europe and North America, the countryside is not wealthier as a whole but in terms of per capita it is (that is people from the country are richer than the people in the cities; generally speaking). This can be due to the fact to lower population density and government subsidies for farmers etc...
Socially Asian people (that come from poorer Asian nations) tend to view peasants from the country with disdain because of the crime rate, poverty, level of education most receive and the perception of backwardness. Again it is the complete opposite in more developed nations, where the quality of basic infrastructure and level of education is almost on par with those from the major cities. And crime rates are generally lower because poverty is almost non-existent. So people's perception of the countryside are generally more positive when compared to people from developed nations. For example take the numerous Western films such as Babe or Smallville; where the countryside is portrayed as clean cut and very peaceful, whereas people from the cities are all cunningly sly and un-contented and usually interfering in the towns folk's peaceful existence.
Spiritually, yes I made this up, it is important to consider many people from poorer Asian nations tend to have ambitions of monetary success. Whereas people in richer regions tend to want a better quality or more fulfilling level of life. This can be due to many factors, but it is probably due to the fact that many Asians are poor and are therefore struggling to survive (e.g China and India) whereas in America people are generally economically sorted so-to-speak. Both are striding for the em-betterment for themselves, but because of their backgrounds both possess different ambitions to try and achieve spiritual content.
These are the differences between China and the USA regarding why the Chinese as a whole do not move to inland regions of China. As for "Do Chinese move to Small Cities"? I would think so out of a population of 1300000000 people, but the surge from the wave caused by those moving from the country to the Eastern cities dwarfs that figure. Lets face it, right now there are more poor in China than there are rich (obviously), but who know in 20 years the trend in China then might be the same as the trend in the USA today.
As the saying goes "money makes the world go round"! There is probably a lot more to add, but I will refrain myself from hijacking this discussion lol...
P.S. Lim
Bob Grant